Educated Guesses: What I've learned about Coconut so far

A place for discussing "coconut" finishes on prewar putz houses, including experiments on "rolling your own."
User avatar
paulrace
Site Admin
Posts: 1682
Joined: Fri Sep 02, 2011 4:27 pm

Re: Educated Guesses: What I've learned about Coconut so fa

Post by paulrace »

The next step is usually pre-cutting to get your straw bits down to less than an inch so you can chop them into coconut-sized bits with your food processor. One contributor who makes his coconut from these wreaths cuts them once to make them into a "log," then feeds the log through a jig he's made that's kind of like a mitre box, using an ubersharp hand saw to cut the straw to >1" links.

I'm working on an article with more detailed information, but I wanted to give you a preview:
rough_cut_jig_coconut 005-001.JPG
rough_cut_jig_coconut 005-001.JPG (66.34 KiB) Viewed 30915 times
rough_cut_jig_coconut 006-001.JPG
rough_cut_jig_coconut 006-001.JPG (121.53 KiB) Viewed 30915 times
User avatar
paulrace
Site Admin
Posts: 1682
Joined: Fri Sep 02, 2011 4:27 pm

Re: Educated Guesses: What I've learned about Coconut so fa

Post by paulrace »

For several of my readers, the next step involves dropping the stuff in a blender or food processor to get it down in size. Generally the first time or two you have to keep stopping the blender to shake the un-chopped stuff down on the blades. You chop, sift out the dust, chop, sift out the dust, chop, sift, and finally, chop, sift out the dust, then sift out the big pieces. Then you're ready for dyeing, not dying, although someone told me that to a lot of coconut makers, life is sift, and then you dye.

No photos of the blender stage yet, sorry.
User avatar
paulrace
Site Admin
Posts: 1682
Joined: Fri Sep 02, 2011 4:27 pm

Re: Educated Guesses: What I've learned about Coconut so fa

Post by paulrace »

For most do-it-yourself coconut makers, dyeing is the next stage. Or bleaching, if you want white coconut. for either, you get the stuff damp - it takes the color or bleach better that way. One way to dye is to use Rit dye. Use a bit of very warm water, a teaspoon or less of dye (to start out), and put on a lid to let set for a half hour.
With bleach, you still get the straw bits damp, but you pour bleach straight on. Don't let it sit for more than a half hour, or the bleach may take the shiny away. In both cases you rinse thoroughly, then press out the extra moisture. Next stop: Drying.

When I told you that the secret of coconut was cellulose and hard work, you really didn't believe me did you?
User avatar
BrianB
Posts: 807
Joined: Thu Jan 24, 2013 8:17 pm
Location: Portland OR
Contact:

Re: Educated Guesses: What I've learned about Coconut so fa

Post by BrianB »

LOVE the straw saw!! :) I'm going to have to work that into my method for sure!!
User avatar
paulrace
Site Admin
Posts: 1682
Joined: Fri Sep 02, 2011 4:27 pm

Re: Educated Guesses: What I've learned about Coconut so fa

Post by paulrace »

Brian, we have more on the straw saw on this page now:

http://cardboardchristmas.com/html/coco ... rials.html
PutzinVT
Posts: 712
Joined: Mon Sep 19, 2011 6:51 pm

Re: Educated Guesses: What I've learned about Coconut so fa

Post by PutzinVT »

Great start to the info in the coconut section.

Thanks Paul.
User avatar
paulrace
Site Admin
Posts: 1682
Joined: Fri Sep 02, 2011 4:27 pm

Re: Educated Guesses: What I've learned about Coconut so fa

Post by paulrace »

Just was reminded that it was Barbara Lovejoy who coined the name "coconut." The article gives her credit now. :-) Thanks, Barb.

I broke the individual subtopics on this forum into separate topics to make it easier to report on one aspect or another without making this particular "topic" sixteen pages long. :-)

Thanks, all who've contributed.
Pete R.Oehmen
Posts: 293
Joined: Fri Sep 16, 2011 9:29 am

Re: Educated Guesses: What I've learned about Coconut so fa

Post by Pete R.Oehmen »

I just read Paul's large article on the making of coconut. He's makes it
sound pretty simple. LOL There are three main hurdles that even I haven't
been able to get over. If someone could break the code on getting
large quantities of CLEAN raw material we could haft the time needed
to manufacture coconut. If we found the right CHOPPER to CUT the
Coconut we could save a bundle of time. If you find a process for
making PURE WHITE COCONUT and retain any of it's original glitter/shine
fast and easy we'd save some time. If anyone finds solutions to these
problems I'll be glad to share other tips. The coloring of coconut is where
the magic of coconut making really takes patients, experimentation and
a small knowledge of chemistry and esthetic art. Coconut by it's characteristics
needs to be shinny. Things like Rice Hulks have none at all. Maria once
sent me a short YouTube video of an Asian man hacking away at a hand full
of rice stalks. You could tell from the 2 videos that the straw is very
dark and a total absents of shine. You can buy some here:
http://www.modernmastersinc.com/product ... up&gid=103
That eliminates Warasusa (Rice Straw). We have the right family
of plants we just don't have the one that the Japanese used. Maybe it's
Stipa Tenuissim? That's my next experiment! We're missing transparency!
User avatar
BrianB
Posts: 807
Joined: Thu Jan 24, 2013 8:17 pm
Location: Portland OR
Contact:

Re: Educated Guesses: What I've learned about Coconut so fa

Post by BrianB »

Hey Pete! I recently had really good luck with a fairly large batch of PURE WHITE coco that didn't loose its shine. It was used on my latest two 10th ave houses if you want to check it out. I may have a few ideas for you, may or may not work with your process. Im still working on chopping of course, but I like a few of the ideas Paul has recently put fourth in his articles. I think Im going to try and get the Ninja blender and straw saw that was contributed on my next batch.
Im still having a problem with light blue coco too, I think Im going to have to start off with white coco instead of raw.???

Definitely not simple!! Several hours goes into making one decent sized batch!

Thanks for the input!!
-Brian
User avatar
paulrace
Site Admin
Posts: 1682
Joined: Fri Sep 02, 2011 4:27 pm

Re: Educated Guesses: What I've learned about Coconut so fa

Post by paulrace »

Pete, thanks for chiming in. I was secretly hoping that you'd got around those hurdles so you weren't sweating blood over each batch like the rest of us.

Notice the name of the main article includes the words "hard work."

I didn't even report on all the things folks have tried and utterly failed with - different kinds of chopping tools, different kinds of prepreocessing, and so on. The Ninja multiple blade food processors are incrementally better than traditional food processors or blenders, but they're not exactly the perfect solution.

Considering that the Japanese who built the original houses did not exactly have a lot of resources, I can only imagine how they chopped the stuff.

My hope is that having articles that go a little deeper than the internet's average articles on putz houses will get some of the folks who don't get all that involved more excited about the hobby. And they'll tell their friends, and they'll tell their friends, and so on. We'll see.

In the meantime, we'll try not to burn out our blenders. :-)
Post Reply